I watched this video a few days ago in which conservative journalist Mary Harrington speaks to a Times of London columnist, James Marriott, about the decline in reading. They get to talking about a new Dark Age, which is a discussion that did not originate with them. The idea is that, like art and culture was lost for a time after the fall of the Roman Empire, we're entering an era in which critical thinking is falling so much by the wayside that we'll lose all sense of which narratives are true or false, effectively leaving us as a culture in which the news of the day is composed of gossip, rumour, and folktales.
Marriott dismissed the idea that some version of Homer's Odyssey will be crafted on TikTok. I don't know if I would categorically rule it out but I've written before about how I feel the real loss as short videos replace full length movies is the loss of crafted sequence, the loss of a thread of logic or feeling replaced by senselessness. So something like TikTok would seem inherently antithetical to a long form story such as The Odyssey. But in another sense, I can see it. A few days later I saw a short AI video of a cat using a prawn to bait and then catch an enormous bass. This particular video was labelled as AI but it was a particularly good AI video. If it hadn't been labelled I imagine it would have fooled a lot of people. I thought back to a time when if you saw a video of something amazing on the internet, you could be reasonable sure it was real. Now I automatically ignore everything that looks extraordinary. But at the same time, I wonder how many people don't care. Someone might say, "Hey, I saw a cat catch this huge bass!" If someone tells him, "Dude, that was AI," well, if anything could be AI, then does it matter? We might get to a point like in antiquity when someone heard a story about Heracles they'd probably take it as true because, well, you have to believe something and is there anything better?
The Renaissance was largely for an elite, educated class. We may be losing that class as education is deteriorated on two fronts, by students cheating using AI and students using the internet to bully and stalk teachers. Teachers themselves coming out of a degraded higher education will lack the skills and emotional discipline to deal with problem students, exacerbating problems that make unruly students, who have been treated without sensitivity and compassion, feel more justified in attacking their teachers, both physically and psychologically. The dimensions of this Pandora's box are hard to see in their totality. So yeah, I can see us heading for a Dark Age (a term many historians shy away from these days but it seems quite appropriate here). The only solution I can imagine is to somehow isolate students from AI and social media until a certain age. There are so many impediments to such a thing, though.
No comments:
Post a Comment