I've a new video essay on YouTube. It's based on the research paper I've been writing over the past several months. I don't expect it'll get a lot of views because it's about H Rider Haggard's She, which I wanted to write about because people haven't been interested in H Rider Haggard's She. It's kind of a catch-22.
One subject I don't talk about in the essay is race. It's a topic with which many commentaries on the book are concerned. The 1965 film adaptation portrays the story as one of a blonde white woman ruling a black African people. The novel is about an Arab woman ruling a people belonging to a non-existent racial group with yellow skin and aquiline noses. She doesn't rule on the basis of race but on the fact that she's immortal and possesses magical powers, like the ability to kill with a thought. And by strategic demonstrations of power, as one of the more famous sections of the book is her speech about how she's compelled to rule by "imagination." Portrayal of race is one of the consistent failings of the film adaptations but I didn't talk about it in the essay because I didn't feel it was an interesting part of the story or interpretations of it.
Most of the film adaptations have a variation on the "empire of the imagination" speech but they're never as good as the original.
"How thinkest thou that I rule this people? I have but a regiment of guards to do my bidding, therefore it is not by force. It is by terror. My empire is of the imagination. Once in a generation mayhap I do as I have done but now, and slay a score by torture. Believe not that I would be cruel, or take vengeance on anything so low. What can it profit me to be avenged on such as these? Those who live long, my Holly, have no passions, save where they have interests. Though I may seem to slay in wrath, or because my mood is crossed, it is not so. Thou hast seen how in the heavens the little clouds blow this way and that without a cause, yet behind them is the great wind sweeping on its path whither it listeth. So it is with me, oh Holly. My moods and changes are the little clouds, and fitfully these seem to turn; but behind them ever blows the great wind of my purpose. Nay, the men must die; and die as I have said."
That bit about "passions" and "interests" recalls the quote, "America has no permanent friends or enemies, only interests," which I thought was Henry Kissinger but Google's AI tells me that's a common mistake, that it's actually likely appropriated from a paraphrase of something said by the British Prime Minister Henry John Temple, Lord Palmerston, "We have no eternal allies, and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual, and those interests it is our duty to follow." The quote is, according to Oxford Reference.com, from an 1848 speech to the House of Commons. So, since She was published in 1886, I guess Haggard may have been thinking of it.
No comments:
Post a Comment