
Wow. Could there be anyone who wasn't pleased with last night's trio of new Andor episodes? I, for one, was captivated. They were written by Tony's brother Dan Gilroy who wrote the Aldani heist arc in the first season. Back then, I wondered if Dan was not a better writer than his brother. Now I really think he is.
Unlike the previous groups of three episodes this season, last night's trio felt like a distinct set of three episodes rather than a single continuous narrative. The first episode, "Messenger", was the first to really feature the Force. No flashing lightsabres, no floating boulders, just a quiet healing scene, but it's enough to really freak Cassian out. The Force Healer senses extraordinary clarity in Andor that stands in contrast to his incredulous exterior. We've seen this in his actions, though. Despite what he says about wanting to get away and live a safe life somewhere far away from war, his instincts always show firm commitment to the cause.
The second episode focused on the Ghorman massacre and also features the heartbreaking conclusion of Syril and Dedra's story. Dedra may be back next week in some capacity but Syril likely will not. It's worth remembering why Syril got into this: he was investigating what he thought was a murder. He was driven by a sense of justice. Unlike most of the Imperial characters we met, he, at least not consciously, was not driven by malice or a desire for personal glory. Finally, he's forced to confront the fact that the Empire isn't what he thought it was and the fact that there's no room for people like him in it. The truth is so contrary to everything he believed that he seems to shut down before he spots Cassian and is spurred to action entirely by sentiment. The episode's title, "Who are You?", is spoken by Cassian when he doesn't recognise Syril. It has a great double impact, not only as a revelation of the disproportionate sense of importance the two men see in each other, but as a precise manifestation of the conflict going on in Syril at that moment. Who, indeed, is he? Without his sense of purpose, perhaps he's nothing at all, which makes it terribly appropriate that this is the moment of his death.

Dedra, meanwhile, is clearly hit hard by the loss of Syril. She was in this for advancement and malice. It was even her idea to manipulate the rebels on Ghorman. Somehow, though, she really did come to love Syril and this has clearly altered her perspective. Denise Gough's performance is amazing. You can see the conflict tearing her apart inside. She really seems damned.
The conflict between truth and reality comes back in Mon Mothma's speech in the next episode in one of those moments that really feels like a commentary on real world politics but not so much as to lock it into an allegory. There were some hints that the situation on Ghorman might have been inspired by the conflict in Gaza and I was very glad the show veered away from making it a direct allegory of that. As it is, you can find parallels to Gaza, Ukraine, World War II France, and many other things.
Apparently, the events in the third episode, "Welcome to the Rebellion", line up with episodes of Star Wars: Rebels but it's still plenty satisfying to those of us who found Rebels to be weak and insubstantial. It's awfully gracious of the Gilroys to preserve continuity like that when I think most people could care less, considering how plainly the writing on Andor is superior.
The show can coast now, these three did the job. But I'm eagerly looking forward to next week anyway.